JavaScript DHTML Menu Powered by Milonic

God new evidence

GOD: new evidence

Contents

The Census by Quirinius

(Unwrapped: the Truth about Christmas #18)

Previous: Born in Bethlehem       Next: Born in a Stable?

Luke says that Joseph and Mary went to Bethlehem because of a census called by the Roman governor Quirinius. But there is no other record of a census in Judea at that time, and Quirinius was not appointed governor until 6 AD, years after Jesus was born.

There is a huge amount that we do not know about the ancient world. Historians say that we have less than one percent of the things that were written at the time. So 99 percent of the evidence has gone missing.

Luke specifically mentions that this was the first census. Maybe he knew that there was a later census – perhaps the better known one in 6 A.D. So it is possible that Luke is talking about an earlier census, at the time of Jesus's birth, but the evidence for it has been lost.

We just do not know the answer about Luke's census. But as we have seen earlier, Luke is a careful historian. Where we can check his account against other sources, it checks out. So does it not make sense to give him the benefit of the doubt here where we can not check?

Did people have to go home for the census?

It is sometimes claimed that there is no historical evidence that the Romans required people to go to their home towns for a census. This is not quite right:

In AD 104, the Roman Prefect of Egypt, Gaius Vivius Maximus, issed an edict saying:

'Seeing that the time has come for the house to house census, it is necessary to compel all those who for any cause whatsoever are residing out of their provinces to return to their own homes, that they may both carry out the regular order of the census and may attend diligently to the cultivation of their allotments.'

So there is clear historical evidence that the Romans could require people to return to thier homes for a census.

 

Here is a longer article about the census and other questions.

To find out more read Luke 1:5-2:30

facebook logo To respond to this video go to www.facebook.com/godnewevidence.

 

only search
'God: new evidence'

Site map


Want to find out if God is real, and to connect with him?
Try Praying

Or get the app:


If you have a question chat now


Give to support our work


Keep in touch:

Facebook Facebook
TwitterTwitter
Get our quarterly newsletter 'In Focus' by email
* indicates required

Privacy Notice

Interesting sites

Bethinking

Christian Evidence Society

Christians in Science

Professor Robin Collins

William Lane Craig - Reasonable Faith

The Demolition Squad

Fixed Point Foundation

Professor Gary Habermas

Professor John Lennox

Reboot

Mike Licona - Risen Jesus

Saints and Sceptics

Test of Faith

Peter S Williams

‘The Universe we live in seems to be a very unlikely place... Are we just lucky? Or is there some deep significance to the fact that we live in a Universe just right for us?’
- New Scientist magazine